Wednesday, 15 October 2008

PM vs Key - who was on top?

ONE NEWS: John Key ought to be pleased with himself on Wednesday morning as he pushed his party's election campaign up there with Labour's after being in its shadow for the first three days.

In Tuesday night's ONE News YouTube leaders debate on TV ONE he was a match for Labour's Helen Clark.

He didn't beat her but he gave as good as he got, delivered a few swift jabs and came out of it smiling.

She could have been harder on him at times, it seemed, and maybe she didn't want to be seen being brutal.

It was a good, old fashioned, feisty head to head between the two candidates who want to lead the next government and voters got a good look at Key under pressure.

Clark got her chances as well, and she used them to leave no doubt about why she thinks she should take Labour into a fourth term.

It's because she has the abilities and the experience to handle a crisis - and that's what New Zealand is facing along with the rest of the world because of the international financial situation.

However, Key has been declared the winner on points of Tuesday night's debate.

The three political journalists involved in the studio debate declared Key the winner.

An unusually high number of viewers cast votes on who they thought won the debate, with Key scoring two to one.

A total of 47,000 took part in the vote with just under 32,000 thought Key won while just over 15,000 voted for Clark.

The economy is going to continue to dominate the election campaign.

Clark and Labour's finance spokesman Michael Cullen have been able to use that to their advantage.

On Sunday she used her campaign launch to announce the bank deposit guarantee scheme, and on Monday she released Labour's universal student allowance policy.

National didn't have anything to match those high impact events, and it was left to quibble about how much it would cost and complain about not being briefed in advance.

And on Tuesday Clark showed another strand of Labour's campaign when she launched billboards which say "Keep it Kiwi".

They're about state-owned assets, which Labour believes is one of National's weakest points.

The billboards focus on Kiwibank, KiwiSaver and KiwiRail, and the message is they won't be safe under National.

In other campaign developments on Tuesday:

Labour's finance spokesman Michael Cullen laid out an economic recovery programme he said would be implemented before the end of the year if Labour wins the election;

National launched its maternity policy, promising to reinstate Plunketline and make sure every new mother and baby would have weekly contact with a lead maternity carer for the first nine weeks;

The Greens were horrified when National said it would scrap the $1 billion home insulation programme. National said it was reckless and wasn't properly funded, the Greens said National's environment record was "abysmal";

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters questioned the cost of Labour's universal student allowance policy. Labour says it will cost $210 million a year, Peters said that was much too low. He supports the policy regardless of the cost; and

Cullen said a Labour government would tell the New Zealand Super Fund to invest more of its cash in New Zealand.

No comments: